Cathy: You’ll Fill Out After Childbirth!

For those of you who don’t read Cathy, her noticably fat in-laws have moved in (with no notice). Cathy went to the mall to try swimsuits alone…and ran into her mother-in-law, who’s trying on a larger size of the same swimsuit.

MIL: You came shopping to escape me, but of course, you can’t do that! You ARE me!

Cathy: What??

MIL: Men are searching for “mom” when they choose their wives, and my son chose you…so you must be just like me!

Cathy: I am NOT you! You’re… You’re…

MIL: [glancing down at her large bust, belly and hips] HOT! I know!

Cathy: [hiding in the dressing room] AACK!!

MIL: Don’t worry. I was scrawny once, too! You’ll fill out after childbirth!

It’s obvious that Cathy is not happy at being compared to her mother-in-law. It’s also obvious that MIL considers herself beautiful just the way she is. As she declares Tuesday: “I’m conscious of my fabulous curves! Conscious of my incredible figure! CONSCIOUS of every inch of my glorious SELF!”

I wasn’t happy when MIL became more prominent in the strip after Cathy and Irving’s marriage, because of course the fat woman was consistently small-minded, overbearing and insensitive. I’m not sure what I think about these strips. You?

Rate this:

Posted

May 26, 2009

Size-Positive Art

Living 400lbs

Tags:

Comments

7 responses to “Cathy: You’ll Fill Out After Childbirth!”

Patsy Nevins

May 27, 2009

I haven’t read Cathy in years & no, I am not fond of the overbearing, interfering mother-in-law image (it is certainly not the kind of MIL I am) & of course the MIL is taking a lot on herself to assume that Cathy will ‘fill out’ after childbirth, etc. However, I do love the woman’s attitude about her own body & her ability to see & appreciate her own beauty. I expect that it is part of Cathy Guisewite’s process of working through her own body image issues. If the MIL can be a positive body image role model for Cathy & her readers, that would be a good thing.

Reply
Trabb's Boy

May 27, 2009

Cathy is far from a fat-positive strip. It sounds to me like the mother-in-law’s body positivity is itself being laughed at — look at the arrogant moron who thinks she looks good! I hope I’m wrong.

Reply
spoonfork

May 27, 2009

This is the first time I’ve read Cathy in a long time, but judging solely from these two strips, I appreciate the MIL’s sense of self—but I really don’t like her tendency to railroad someone who isn’t quite so accepting.

I really hope that Guisewite isn’t making the assumption that the MIL is delusional as well as overbearing. And I hope that Cathy, who has been the body-hatred poster child from the get-go, will finally be able to accept herself. regardless of where the message comes from.

Of course, that’s a lot to ask of four small panels.

Maybe the MIL should just leave a copy of Lessons from the Fatosphere on Cathy’s coffee table when she leaves?

Reply
1. living400lbs
  
  May 27, 2009
  
  Yes. I note that both Cathy and the MIL have an image of the “correct” body type – they’re just different images.
  
  Reply
Piffle

May 27, 2009

I think she’s playing into the tired old MIL stereotypes. I haven’t read Cathy in a long time because she just had this little loop of neuroses. It’s nice to see some fat positivity in a comic strip, particularly one as pointed towards women as Cathy.

Reply
1. living400lbs
  
  May 27, 2009
  
  Cathy Guisewite has stated that she organizes the strip around “the four basic guilt groups” – love, food, work, and mom.
  
  Reply
Clover

May 27, 2009

I am waiting to see where this one goes. If it just squashes the MIL because she’s FAT, duh, I will be disappointed! It’s kind of a shame that the person who is accepting of their body is a really unlikable character in every other sense.

Reply