In context

BMI doesn’t tell you much, but it does tend to show a bell-style curve over a large population.

BMI distribution in Mississippi, 2003

The chart at right, showing population distribution of BMIs from Mississippi in 2003, (source) gives you a rough idea.

My BMI is about 60.  That chart? Doesn’t even show anyone of BMI 60.

The official definition of “obese” used to be based on height/weight tables, which roughly corresponded to

  • Overweight is BMI of 27 or more for women, 28 or more for men;
  • Obese is BMI of 32 or above

In June 1998 the definition was changed:

  • Overweight is BMI of 25 of more;
  • Obese is BMI of 30 or more.

Remember that chart?  The mean, or average BMI in that population was 27.73. This is not all that abnormal for the US; most “officially obese” folks have a BMI under 40.

Want to know what a person with a BMI of 25, 30, or 40 looks like?  Check out The BMI Project’s slideshow and Flickr set.  Those are typical obese people.

If you are wondering how this looks in pounds, the following table is from the CDC (PDF):

Table1. Body mass index (BMI) values for healthy weight, overweight, and obesity

Corresponding weight in pounds (approximate)
Weight BMI values Man 5’9’’ tall
(average height)
Woman 5’4’’ tall
(average height)
Healthy weight 18.5–24.9 121–163 108–144
Overweight 25.0–29.9 164–195 145–173
Obese 30 and above 196 and above 174 and above
And, getting out my calculator to add:
Morbidly Obese 40 and above 270 and above 232.5 and above

Many news stories about weight illustrate with pictures of extremely fat folk such as myself. The reality is that most “obese” people are not extremely fat.  Most obese folks can buy clothing at department stores.  They may not even need to go to the “plus” size department!

All this is to make it clear that when I say my body is not typical, I’m NOT KIDDING.  K?


Note: The “Healthy Weight” category description is verbatim from the CDC.  Data from the Health and Retirement Survey (PDF) shows that “[a] low ‘normal weight’ results in a higher mortality rate than overweight does.”  See also “Association of All-Cause Mortality With Overweight and Obesity Using Standard Body Mass Index Categories,” Journal of the American Medical Association.

Note 2:Apparently some references use “severe obesity” for people whose BMI is greater than 40. They also divide that between “morbid obesity” (BMI of 40-50) and “super obesity” or “super obese” (BMI greater than 50).  But again, most people’s BMI is below 40.


Posted

in

, ,

by

Tags:

Comments

17 responses to “In context”

  1. Debra Avatar

    A thin person with little muscle tone could be considered obese, as obesity is defined by a high percentage of body fat. I’ve always found that kind of funny.

  2. living400lbs Avatar

    Mostly I’ve seen body-fat percentage as a mitigating factor, such as “bodybuilders have high BMIs but they are low in body fat”.

    But when you’re at the doctor’s office, do they use a scale or do they measure body fat?

    Oh, and the CDC site doesn’t give body fat % targets at all. Just BMI. Wikipedia mentions both, but again, BMI is the official definition.

    (I am curious about my body fat %, and have considered getting it measured a couple ways just to see what variations there might be. :)

  3. randomquorum Avatar
    randomquorum

    I totally agree on the % bodyfat thing.

    When I was young I was an elite gymnast, and they used to assess our bodyfat using skinfolds quite often (I can’t remember how often it was). I don’t recall ever being weighed though.

    It was still somewhat traumatic but fortunately at the time my results were always in the “acceptable” range. They would want to be, for 32 hours training a week at age 12!

    I do wonder though if this has impacted on me since – mentally or physically. Is it possible for your metabolism to be wonky as a result of extreme exercising when you’re young?

  4. Schrodinger Avatar
    Schrodinger

    Getting a caliper test done, to measure bodyfat, was an interesting experience for me. In terms of determining your bodyfat percentage, it’s significantly better than a bmi chart. However, in terms of an overall picture of health it makes a lot more sense to have your blood pressure checked and cholesterol counted. Most people could probably estimate their bodyfat within a couple percentage points, but would have a hard time blind-guessing their blood pressure, LDL and HDL levels.

  5. friendly daughter Avatar
    friendly daughter

    Yeah, I was perfectly astonished to find myself in the “obese” category immediately after having my last child.

    It’s not nearly so visually shocking as some people seem to imagine it is. I was still considerably taller than I was wide, for instance. LOL.

    It didn’t last long, though. Now I’m merely Overweight. Barely. Such is life.

    My mom’s the archetypal Fat Woman, though. Seriously, bigger than a lot of those “Fat American Beast” cameos in the news.

    Always thought it was odd that her portion sizes seemed so…. unremarkable.

    You’d guess that really fat people would have to shovel it in 8 hours a day to stay that fat, but they’re really much more like the rest of us than many of us would like to imagine.

    anyway, party on, fat bloggers!

  6. Patsy Avatar

    You know, I used to weigh more than you do now. I’m a 6ft tall female and […] I’m currently over 300lbs and my goal weight is around the 200 – 210lbs mark. Although I’ll be at the top end of the ‘overweight’ range, I think, as I’m currently doing a lot of exercise and weight training, that I’ll look the best I ever have!

    I commend you for being happy with your size, keeping mobile and promoting ‘fat acceptance’, something I knew nothing about until I came across your blog. I’m losing the weight again because I had a baby girl 6 months ago and I really want to be slimmer and healthy for her. Not to mention, everyday life was a whole lot easier when I weighed less than 250lbs than when I was over 400 – something I started to take for granted when I was slimmer and now desperately miss!

    Bye for now

    Patsy :o)

  7. […] Putting 400 lbs In Context, or no, I am not a "typical-size" fat person. […]

  8. […] a middle seat between people who don’t want to brush my shoulders.  If they complain about me, what do you think is going to happen?  I buy a second seat or get […]

  9. hopeandpray Avatar
    hopeandpray

    BMI is crazy! it doesn’t take into account that muscle weighs more than fat. when i got healthy (not skinny, fit) i stayed the exact same weight because i lost fat and gained muscle

  10. […] I’ve lost 10% of my baseline weight many, many times in my life.  I’ve never had a parent, teacher, or medical professional congratulate me for it.   The closest I ever got was being told to “keep it up”.   Because 10% is not enough. Because I was still fat. If losing 10% of your current weight would get you into the “normal weight” range, you’re not very fat.  (Of course, most people who are fat aren’t very fat.) […]

  11. yaoirox666 Avatar
    yaoirox666

    BMI drives me nuts. <.<

  12. […] that are illustrated with photos of very fat people like myself, and assumes that I’m a typically-sized […]

  13. […]  Really!!!  You might be fat and not know it!!!  (eeek!)  And since most people who are “overweight or obese” aren’t actually very fat, increasing the number of people who think they need to lose weight can increase customers for the […]

  14. […] be a 5% loss from baseline.  Not “reducing BMI to “normal”".   Losing 5%.   If losing 5% of your weight would put you in the “normal” BMI bracket, it’s likely you’re there […]

  15. […] Discussion of BMI is as a definition of “obese” is here […]

  16. The AMA is Wrong | Everblog Avatar

    […] of early death than those of “normal” body size (BMI 18.5 to 24.9).  Most people who fit the clinical definition of obese are in the smaller […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: